Boris Johnson was handed his first Parliamentary defeat since the general election today as the House of Lords defied him over Brexit.The upper chamber backed a cross-party amendment seeking to force the Government to provide EU citizens with physical proof of their right to remain in the UK after January 31.
It was tabled by Liberal Democrat Lord Oates, who argued EU citizens covered by the settled status scheme should have the right to a physical form of proof of status instead of only the digital proof proposed by the Government.
He said that without physical documentation EU citizens eligible to remain in the UK would be ‘severely disadvantaged’ in dealings with landlords, airlines and other officials.He denied it was an attempt to challenge Brexit or ‘frustrate’ the legislation, which has already passed through the Commons with big majorities ahead of Brexit day on January 31.
It was passed this afternoon by 270 votes to 229, majority 41. Afterwards Lord Oates said: ‘This amendment simply seeks to uphold the promise repeatedly made by Boris Johnson that the rights of EU citizens to remain in the UK would be automatically guaranteed.
‘It would remove the risk that those who failed to meet the cut off deadline would be automatically criminalised and subject to deportation.
‘ Lord Oates said EU citizens covered by the settled status scheme should have the right to a physical form of proof of status instead of only the digital proof proposed by the GovernmentThe upper chamber backed a cross-party amendment seeking to force the Government to provide EU citizens with physical proof of their right to remain in the UK after January 31Lord Oates had earlier said the right to remain should also be based on eligibility and not forfeited by failing to meet an arbitrary deadline under a cut-off date in June 2021, which could lead to EU citizens being ‘criminalised’ afterwards.
Without physical proof of right of residence, there was bound to be ‘confusion’ and ‘anxiety’ for such people in their dealings with officials post-Brexit.’In the real world, in respect of permanent residence, proof of immigration status is in physical documentation,’ Lord Oates said.
‘That’s what people are used to.’EU citizens are going to be severely disadvantaged if they don’t have it.’Backing the demand, independent crossbencher Lord Warner questioned whether the Home Office computer system could be relied on to provide digital proof of status all the year round.
Former senior civil servant Lord Kerslake said providing physical proof of settled status would not delay the UK’s departure from the EU.The independent crossbench peer said: ‘Agreeing our amendment need not delay Brexit, not does it require changes to the Withdrawal Agreement.
‘Tory peer Viscount Ridley warned that the amendment could lead to the introduction of identity cards for EU citizens.He said: ‘I think it’s not impossible that we would get to a situation, whether intended or not, whereby people would be asked to produce proof in this form if there was physical identity documentation in existence.
‘And it would, therefore, become by the backdoor an identity card required of EU citizens but not UK citizens.’That would seem to me to be a worrying development.’ Home Office minister Baroness Williams of Trafford had warned that the amendment could lead to ‘ID card creep’.She said: ‘I totally agree with my noble friend, the noble Viscount Ridley, and his point about ID card creep is also part of this point.’And it’s exactly what happened to the Windrush generation.
‘The Government is adamant that we must avoid the situation where years down the line EU citizens who have built their lives here find them
Boris Johnson's EU Withdrawal Bill suffered three defeats in the House of Lords Peers backed move to give EU citizens more than just a digital document Ruled ministers should not decide who can ignore European Court judgments And said cases should be referred to Supreme Court to depart from EU case law Bill will now return to the Commons where the peers' rulings will be overturned Boris Johnson's Brexit deal has suffered three defeats in the Lords and will now have to go back to the Commons.